Writing & Content domain-authoritycitation-trustseo-geobacklink-analysisentity-evidenceaudit-gates

Domain Authority Auditor

Assess a domain’s citation trust against a declared peer cohort using dated, auditable evidence.

FollowSkills review · FSRS-2.0
Use with care
65/ 100 5-point scale 3.3 / 5
Trust20 / 25 · 4.0/5

The skill specifies least-scope inputs, permissioned v3 artifact writes, explicit authorization before persistence, and fail-closed handling for unknown evidence, fetched content, robots.txt, penalties, and data-egress risks. The Apache-2.0 license, security policy, zero-dependency design, and no-key-storage statements add supporting safeguards. Deduction: the file does not fully expose runtime permissions, rollback implementation, or sensitive-data classification, and publisher identity is unverified by the FollowSkills enterprise registry.

Reliability9 / 20 · 2.3/5

Inputs, prerequisites, 40-item state handling, Unknown semantics, NOT_SCORED behavior when the runtime is unavailable, validation checkpoints, and failure routing are explicit and internally consistent. Deduction: the workflow depends on several external reference files, scripts, and a deterministic runtime whose reachability is not demonstrated here; no execution reproduction is available, so static calibration keeps this below the 10-point ceiling.

Adaptability12 / 15 · 4.0/5

Trigger conditions, non-fit cases, argument hint, required market/stage/domain-type/cohort context, and routing to adjacent auditors are clear. It is keyless by default, targets Claude Code and compatible agent-skill hosts, and includes Chinese metadata and summary text. Deduction: mainland-China reachability of external evidence sources is not established, Chinese-language support is limited mainly to metadata/short labels, and boundary examples are sparse.

Convention12 / 15 · 4.0/5

The skill has version 18.0.0, Apache-2.0 licensing, a Quick Start, Skill Contract, data-source table, layered procedure, validation checkpoints, persistence limits, references, and Next Best Skill links. The README, license, security policy, version signals, and CI provide shared maintenance evidence. Deduction: the selected skill does not itself identify a maintenance owner, changelog, or update path, and dependency/install failure guidance is distributed across runtime rules rather than consolidated.

Effectiveness7 / 15 · 2.3/5

The skill turns domain-authority auditing into a locked peer cohort, a 40-item evidence state model, veto verification, and a structured report with actionable follow-up, which is directly useful for reducing manual omissions. Deduction: no real execution result is available, and there is no verified representative output across domain profiles; the example is reference prose rather than proof of correctness, so static calibration limits effectiveness to 7.

Verifiability5 / 10 · 2.5/5

The skill defines a fixed CITE framework, 40 stable items, dated/source-backed evidence requirements, Unknown/N/A rules, validation commands, and an example report. Shared repository CI and security/architecture tests provide some corroborating maintenance evidence. Deduction: there is no skill-specific real CI coverage, committed execution artifact, or independent third-party corroboration in the supplied material; the example is author-provided, so static calibration limits verifiability to 5.

Evidence confidence:Low Reviewed Jul 20, 2026 Reviewed revision ebd436747f8f
The upstream repository has new commits since this review. The score still applies to the reviewed revision shown and may not cover the latest changes.
Before you use it
  • Do not emit a numeric score or gate verdict without a locked peer cohort, market, entity stage, and domain type; return NEEDS_INPUT/UNDECIDED instead.
  • This review did not execute scripts, fetch data, or verify external citations; deployment should confirm that all referenced files, runtime scripts, and the repository root are reachable.
  • Before crawling third-party domains, confirm authorization and respect robots.txt, applicable TDM reservation signals, and site terms; lack of private-console access must not be treated as proof of a penalty.
See the full review method →

What does this skill do, and when should you use it?

This skill evaluates one domain’s trust, identity, link, and citation-authority signals relative to a locked peer cohort. It runs a 40-item CITE audit and records evidence coverage, Unknown states, and verified manipulation or penalty vetoes. A complete score requires the market, entity stage, domain type, peer cohort, and dated evidence; missing context produces NEEDS_INPUT/UNDECIDED instead of a total score. It fits structured SEO/GEO authority reviews, not page-level content-quality audits or backlink-only diagnosis.

Reads one normalized domain, market, entity stage, domain profile, locked peer cohort, and dated link, identity, trust, eminence, and citation evidence; assigns all 40 CITE items an evidence-backed state, Unknown, or authorized N/A; verifies CITE-T03, CITE-T05, and CITE-T09 veto conditions; runs the Python scorer when the verified runtime is available; preserves score, coverage, and confidence; and produces SHIP, FIX, BLOCK, or UNDECIDED outcomes. After explicit authorization, it validates and persists a v3 audit artifact.

  1. An SEO lead needs a peer-relative CITE baseline for a SaaS domain against same-stage U.S. competitors.
  2. A GEO team needs to assess whether a website has domain-level evidence supporting citation trust.
  3. A brand team sees unusual link growth, traffic incoherence, or indexing changes and needs a structured manipulation or penalty review.
  4. An auditor has backlink, entity, and search-visibility exports and needs a machine-checkable domain authority report.

What are this skill's strengths and limitations?

Pros
  • Uses a 40-item CITE framework covering identity, links, trust, and eminence through peer-relative comparison.
  • Explicitly distinguishes Unknown, N/A, estimated, proxy, and user-provided evidence instead of treating missing data as failure.
  • Defines positive verification rules for link/traffic incoherence, manipulation networks, and active manual actions or material deindexing.
  • Supports structured scoring, validation, coverage, confidence, and permission-controlled v3 artifacts.
Limitations
  • A complete score depends on a locked peer cohort and dated evidence; missing backlink or private-console data leaves items Unknown.
  • It does not perform page-level content-quality audits, backlink-only diagnosis, or entity repair; those are routed to other skills.
  • The supplied source does not include independent test results for this individual skill or the full contents of its referenced runtime files.

How do you install this skill?

Install the repository with: git clone https://github.com/aaron-he-zhu/aaron-marketing-skills. In Claude Code, use /plugin marketplace add aaron-he-zhu/aaron-marketing-skills, then /plugin install aaron-marketing@aaron. The README does not document a dedicated single-skill installation command; the skill identifies Claude Code and compatible Agent Skills hosts as compatible.

How do you use this skill?

Use a prompt such as: "Audit example.com against these five same-stage U.S. SaaS peers. Run the CITE content-publisher profile; mark every private-data gap Unknown." Provide the canonical domain, observation date, market, entity stage, domain type, cohort inclusion rules, and evidence window. Without the market, stage, domain type, or peer cohort, the skill should return NEEDS_INPUT/UNDECIDED.

How does this skill compare with similar options?

Compared with content-quality-auditor, this skill evaluates domain-level authority and citation trust rather than page-level content quality. Compared with offsite-signal-analyzer, it applies CITE scoring and veto gates instead of performing backlink diagnosis without a gate. entity-registry is the alternative for canonical entity repair.

FAQ

Can it produce a score without private Search Console or analytics data?
Not necessarily. Affected items should remain Unknown, and the result may be NEEDS_INPUT/UNDECIDED rather than an automatic failure.
Does it modify the website or submit external data?
No. It only writes a v3 audit artifact after explicit authorization; the audit request does not authorize cache, candidate, or registry writes.
Does a young domain or WHOIS privacy automatically fail the audit?
No. Domain age, WHOIS privacy, low absolute volume, or missing private-console access cannot alone trigger a veto.
When should I use another skill?
Use content-quality-auditor for page quality, offsite-signal-analyzer for ungated link diagnosis, and entity-registry for entity-state repair.

More skills from this repository

All from aaron-he-zhu/aaron-marketing-skills

Writing & Content

Off-Site & AI Referral Analyzer

Audit backlink quality and measure traffic and conversions from AI assistants.

Writing & Content

Content Quality Auditor

Audit content quality and publication readiness with an evidence-based CORE-EEAT review.

Writing & Content

Competitor SEO & GEO Analyst

Turn competitor keywords, content, backlinks, AI citations, and traffic share into an actionable SEO strategy.

Writing & Content

Site Structure Optimizer

Design a clearer site hierarchy and strengthen internal links so important pages connect better.

Writing & Content

Page Play Builder: Scaled SEO Page Builder

A guarded router for building programmatic, comparison, parasite, and local SEO pages.

Writing & Content

SEO Performance Monitor

Build source-tagged SEO/GEO performance reports and configure alerts for ranking, traffic, and AI-visibility changes.

Writing & Content

Content Gap Analysis

Compare your content coverage with competitors to prioritize missing topics, keyword opportunities, and editorial work.

Writing & Content

RAMP Launch Readiness Auditor

Audits launch evidence by lifecycle stage so teams can make a traceable go/no-go decision.

Data & Analysis

Entity Registry

Maintain machine-readable entity identity, Knowledge Graph facts, and AI recognition evidence.

Writing & Content

SERP Markup Builder

Create paste-ready titles, meta descriptions, social tags, and structured data for a page head.

Writing & Content

SERP Analysis

Assess whether a query is realistically targetable by mapping its SERP structure, ranking patterns, and feature opportunities.

Writing & Content

SEO Content Writer & Refresh Planner

Create search-intent-led SEO pages or diagnose content decay with a prioritized refresh plan.

Writing & Content

Keyword Research & Content Planning

Discover, score, and cluster search terms into an actionable SEO/GEO content plan.

Writing & Content

On-Page SEO Checker

Diagnose single-page SEO problems and turn them into prioritized, actionable fixes.

Writing & Content

GEO Citation Optimizer

Make existing content easier for ChatGPT, Perplexity, and other AI search systems to understand and cite.

Writing & Content

Rank Tracker

Monitor keyword positions, SERP features, and AI-search visibility over time.

Writing & Content

Social Quality Gate

Pre-publish social audits for channel truth, claims, disclosures, UGC rights, manipulation, and measurement integrity.

Writing & Content

Email List Segment Builder

Build reusable email audiences and suppression lists from first-party customer data.

Writing & Content

Narrative Quality Gate

Audit brand-narrative truth, system coherence, and effectiveness evidence as separate profiles.

Writing & Content

Offer & Claims Registry

Keep marketing claims and offers tied to exact wording, evidence, disclosures, terms, and review dates.

Related skills