NVIDIA DOCA Public Knowledge Map

The skill mainly routes to documentation, paths, and forums; it requests no credentials, gives no destructive defaults, separates hardware mutation into a safety skill, and points to authoritative sources. Points are deducted because it does not systematically disclose network data flows, user-confirmation boundaries, privacy handling, or rollback procedures.

SKILL.md provides detailed triggers, routing tables, discovery questions, prerequisites, and out-of-scope handoffs, with supporting material in references/map.md. However, static files do not prove that key paths run, the benchmark dataset is unavailable, some referenced material was not fully verifiable in this review, and abnormal-input failure feedback is thin; therefore the score stays below the static ceiling of 10.

The audience, common question shapes, non-goals, and implicit triggers are described fairly clearly, covering local installs, public documentation, GitHub, and NGC routing. Points are deducted because the trigger language initially broadens to nearly any DOCA question, Chinese-language support is not demonstrated, and mainland-China reachability or fallback paths for docs.nvidia.com, GitHub, and forums are not addressed.

The documentation uses progressive disclosure, moving detailed tables into references/map.md, and includes related skills, examples, dependencies, and version clues. Points are deducted for missing recommended Instructions and Examples sections in SKILL.md, missing author metadata, inconsistent license wording between the front matter, skill card, and repository license, a version mismatch between the card and assessed revision, and limited skill-specific maintenance and changelog information.

The routing tables are directly useful for locating authoritative DOCA documentation, install paths, samples, and renamed URLs, and the skill requires environment discovery before recommendations. Points are deducted because the skill does not itself provide tutorials or verified results, many outcomes depend on later network access or live-install inspection, and the benchmark claims cannot be independently checked because its source dataset is absent; static calibration therefore limits the score to 7 or below.

The files contain many concrete URLs, paths, commands, and cross-references, while BENCHMARK.md supplies a limited evaluation summary. Points are deducted because external links were not independently validated here, the benchmark dataset and full trial records are missing, and no committed test suite covers the key routing paths; under static calibration the score cannot exceed 5.